devarshi-dt-logo

Question:

The ratio of the weights of a body on the Earth's surface to that on the surface of a planet is 9:4. The mass of the planet is 1/9th that of the Earth. If 'R' is the radius of the Earth, what is the radius of the planet?

R4

R3

R2

R9

Solution:

Correct option is B. R2
Since mass of the object remains same
∴Weight of object will be proportional to 'g'(acceleration due to gravity)
Given
Wearth/Wplanet = 9/4
gearth/gplanet
Also, gsurface = GM/R² (M is mass planet, G is universal gravitational constant, R is radius of planet)
∴9/4 = (GMearth/Rplanet²)/(GMplanet/Rearth²)= (Mearth/Mplanet) × (Rplanet²/Rearth²)= 9(Rplanet²/Rearth²)
∴Rplanet/Rearth = √(1/9) = 1/3
∴Rplanet = Rearth/3 = R/3

There appears to be a mistake in the provided solution. The equation correctly derives that the ratio of radii is 1/3, not 1/2. Let's re-examine the steps:

  1. Weight Ratio: The ratio of weights is directly proportional to the ratio of accelerations due to gravity: Wearth/Wplanet = gearth/gplanet = 9/4
  2. Gravity Equation: The acceleration due to gravity on the surface of a planet is given by: g = GM/R², where G is the gravitational constant, M is the planet's mass, and R is its radius.
  3. Ratio of Gravities: Substituting the gravity equation into the weight ratio gives:
    (GMearth/Rearth²)/(GMplanet/Rplanet²) = 9/4
  4. Simplifying: This simplifies to:
    (Mearth/Mplanet) * (Rplanet²/Rearth²) = 9/4
  5. Given Mass Ratio: We are given that Mplanet = (1/9)Mearth. Substituting this into the equation gives:
    (Mearth/((1/9)Mearth)) * (Rplanet²/Rearth²) = 9/4
  6. Solving for Radius Ratio: This simplifies to:
    9 * (Rplanet²/Rearth²) = 9/4
    (Rplanet²/Rearth²) = 1/4
    Rplanet/Rearth = 1/2
  7. Radius of Planet: Therefore, Rplanet = (1/2)Rearth = R/2

Therefore, the radius of the planet is R/2. The provided solution contains a calculation error. The correct answer is not present in the options. The correct option should be R/2